Historial cara a cara

• 29 Aug 2026 York 2 : 1 Exeter City League Two
• 16 Feb 2016 York 2 : 0 Exeter City League Two
• 22 Aug 2015 Exeter City 0 : 0 York League Two
• 28 Feb 2015 York 0 : 0 Exeter City League Two
• 23 Aug 2014 Exeter City 1 : 1 York League Two